Stay Realm Logo

Discover

Hotels

Settings

Currency
Language
Loading...
9.1 / 10 Guest Rating

The Madison Fire Island Pines

22 Atlantic Walk, Fire Island Pines, us

The Madison Fire Island Pines - main view

About the Property

Luxurious Accommodation: Stay at The Madison Fire Island Pines, adults-only guest house, offering stunning pool and garden views from all units along with free WiFi and cozy bed linen.

Relaxation & Recreation: Unwind by the outdoor swimming pool or soak up the sun on the terrace, perfect for a relaxing getaway at Fire Island Pines.

Delicious Breakfast: Start your day with a scrumptious continental breakfast included during your stay, adding a delightful touch to your experience at our tranquil retreat.

Book your stay at The Madison Fire Island Pines now for a peaceful and rejuvenating escape.

Facilities & Amenities

Non-smoking rooms
Air conditioning
Swimming pool
Terrace
Pets allowed
Non-smoking throughout
Heated pool
Adult only
Cashless payment available
First aid kit available

Important Information

Check-in & Out

Check-in
Check-out12:00 PM

Property Notes

Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply. This property does not accommodate bachelor(ette) or similar parties. A deposit may be required at the property.

Check Room Availability

1 night · 2 adults

No rooms available

We couldn't find any available rooms for these dates and guests. Try adjusting your search criteria.

Guest Reviews

9.1
Exceptional36 verified reviews
AI Summary

Guests highly rate the welcoming staff and frequently praise the great location.

Categories

Cleanliness8.2
Service10.0
Location9.7
Room Quality8.7
Amenities9.2
Value for Money8.5
Food and Beverage8.7
Overall Experience9.7

Select topics to read reviews

T
TinausUS
Verified booking
extended_group
Standard Room
Stayed in Jan 19, 2026

"Exceptional"

9.0

The caretakers were wonderful!!!!

The ants

Helpful?
J
JohnusUS
Verified booking
couple
Standard Room
Stayed in Oct 9, 2025

"Exceptional"

10.0
Helpful?
T
TiphainegbGB
Verified booking
solo_traveller
Standard Room
Stayed in Sep 30, 2025

"Unexpected break close to Manhattan"

10.0

Quiet place, close to the beach and ferry, Zach was kind and welcoming, making me feel welcome. Warmed swimming pool with only hearing crickets! Feel between Hawaii for the beach and French Rivera in the hotel, but on quiet mode! What i wanted! Towels, chair and umbrella for the beach!

The issue was to regulate the temperature in the room, too cold for me. Note for next time: Need to ask when you have the key how to manage it. Note for travelers for the village (not the hotel). Very expensive small grocery shop (but high diversity in the choice for the food that reduced the pain associated with high price).

Helpful?
A
ArthurusUS
Verified booking
extended_group
Standard Room
Stayed in Sep 29, 2025

"Very satisfied. Would stay at the Madison again should the opportunity presents."

10.0

Zack was very nice and accommodating. He was a great help in facilitating our stay.

N/A - The accommodations met our expectations.

Helpful?
J
Jennifer
Verified booking
Standard Room
Stayed in Sep 25, 2025

"Exceptional"

10.0

Absolutely wonderful way to spend our 20th anniversary! The property was magical. We especially enjoyed the super warm pool and excellent breakfast! Zach was particularly warm and welcoming. We can’t wait to come back! Highly recommend. ❤️🧡💛💚💙💜

Helpful?
S
Shavkat
Verified booking
Standard Room
Stayed in Sep 24, 2025

"Exceptional"

10.0

We love this place. We fell like home. Zack was very helpful,he explained us everything about Island.We can’t wait to go back again. Thank you guys;Zack and Mike

Helpful?
P
PatrickusUS
Verified booking
couple
Standard Room
Stayed in Sep 6, 2025

"Perfect location and private suite to enjoy your stay in FIP."

10.0

The location was great. Short walking distance to the ferry, market, liquor shops, and bar/clubs. Can't beat it.

Nothing

Helpful?
J
JeffreyusUS
Verified booking
solo_traveller
Standard Room
Stayed in Aug 5, 2025

"Exceptional"

10.0
Helpful?
X
Xiaogang
Verified booking
Standard Room
Stayed in Aug 4, 2025

"Exceptional"

10.0

Great place

Helpful?
K
KristiandeDE
Verified booking
couple
Standard Room
Stayed in Jul 28, 2025

"Die Insel ist traumhaft"

4.0

Die Insel ist unglaublich schön und man könnte wesentlich mehr aus der Unterkunft herausholen.

Bei der Ausstattung, dem reparaturbedürftigen Zustand der schlechten Sauberkeit dem dürftigen Frühstück ist der Preis völlig überteuert wenn man ein wesentlich besseres Hotel zum halben Preis in bester Lage in Manhattan bekommt.

Helpful?
Next
1
234