Stay Realm Logo

Discover

Hotels

Settings

Currency
Language
Loading...
8.4 / 10 Guest Rating

Athenaeum Hotel

3 S Lake Dr, Mayville, New York, 14757, Mayville, US

Athenaeum Hotel - main view

About the Property

Stunning Garden Views
Enjoy the picturesque garden views surrounding Athenaeum Hotel. Stay connected with complimentary wireless internet and take advantage of concierge services during your stay.

Delicious Dining and Lounge
Indulge in a satisfying meal at Heirloom restaurant or unwind with a drink at the bar/lounge. A perfect way to end your day at our hotel.

Convenient Amenities and Meeting Spaces
Benefit from amenities like a 24-hour front desk, luggage storage, and safety deposit boxes. Our hotel also offers 2 meeting rooms for your events.

Located steps away from Chautauqua Amphitheater and Chautauqua Lake, Athenaeum Hotel in Chautauqua provides a perfect retreat. Book your stay with us now to experience a blend of comfort and convenience.

Facilities & Amenities

Fireplace in lobby
Free WiFi
24-hour front desk
Garden
Luggage storage
Concierge service
Elevator
Fireplace in lobby
Television in common areas
Safe-deposit box at front desk

Important Information

Check-in & Out

Check-in
Check-out10:00 AM

Property Notes

Contactless check-out is available.

Check Room Availability

1 night · 2 adults

No rooms available

We couldn't find any available rooms for these dates and guests. Try adjusting your search criteria.

Guest Reviews

8.4
Excellent129 verified reviews
AI Summary

Guests highly rate the charming atmosphere and frequently praise the accommodating staff.

Categories

Cleanliness8.0
Service8.9
Location9.0
Room Quality8.4
Amenities8.5
Value for Money7.9
Food and Beverage7.5
Overall Experience8.9

Select topics to read reviews

L
Lisa
Verified booking
partner
Standard Room
Stayed in Oct 5, 2025

"Exceptional"

10.0

The lake view at sunrise is a beautiful way to start your day. Staff is exceptional and friendly, breakfast is fresh and plentiful.

Helpful?
W
William
Verified booking
Standard Room
Stayed in Oct 5, 2025

"Excellent"

8.0

We did not get a lake room, but the porch and yard are a great place to relax.

Helpful?
G
Gloria
Verified booking
Standard Room
Stayed in Oct 4, 2025

"Excellent"

8.0

Beautiful location on the Chautauqua Institute grounds. Beautiful lobby, porches facing lake, plenty of grounds to enjoy. The hotel rooms are in need of much refreshing. Cracked linoleum and severe sloping bathroom floor. Carpets very dirty and spotted. Due for updating. Do not count on eating at the bar and snack area in rhe lobby, not in the Heirloom Room for dinner. The three nights we were there, they had weddings and events. So were closed to hotel guests.

Helpful?
B
Bernard
Verified booking
Standard Room
Stayed in Oct 4, 2025

"Exceptional"

10.0

Great breakfast... fog in the morning prevented a lake view...

Helpful?
R
ronald
Verified booking
Standard Room
Stayed in Oct 3, 2025

"Athenaeum - Sept. 2025"

10.0

We enjoyed stepping back in time to admire the unique building style of the 1880's. The room was a little smaller than most hotels, except New York City, but was very comfortable. It was a very pleasant experience staying at the Athenaeum Hotel and very relaxing. Also, the "Continental Breakfast" was way beyond the norm...excellent. There were plenty of choices and stocked very well. This was indeed an unexpected bonus. Lastly, walking around the hotel and Chatauqua Institution was very enjoyable.

Helpful?
B
Brandon
Verified booking
Standard Room
Stayed in Oct 2, 2025

"Excellent"

8.0

The hotel was exceptionally clean, the staff was very friendly and cooperative. The bed was hard and very small, really my only complaint.

Helpful?
G
greg
Verified booking
partner
Standard Room
Stayed in Oct 2, 2025

"Exceptional"

10.0

Very welcoming to our dog. Very friendly staff

Helpful?
J
Jared
Verified booking
partner
Standard Room
Stayed in Sep 28, 2025

"Excellent"

8.0

The hotel itself is quite lovely. Very old world 1890s era charm and craftsmanship. The room was pleasant and clean, very high ceilings and large windows. The bed was very comfortable. With all that said, the hotel was built before cars. It's very tight and we did not expect to have to park appropriately 1/8th mile away. We are perfectly capable of the walk, and they do offer valet parking and shuttle options. But I feel they should make that known for older folks. Also the bathroom, clean as it was, left me a bit disappointed. Everything worked, but the shower was sad. The staff we dealt with was mostly pleasant and helpful. If you wish to have a view of the lake, you want the East side of the hotel I believe

Helpful?
S
Susan
Verified booking
partner
Standard Room
Stayed in Sep 26, 2025

"Exceptional"

10.0

We love the charm and beautiful scenery around the hotel. Hotel staff are more than accommodating. We will definitely visit again.

Helpful?
S
Sara
Verified booking
Standard Room
Stayed in Sep 25, 2025

"Good"

6.0

I was given the noisiest room in the hotel unfortunately.

Helpful?