Sugar Mill Hotel

Amazing food and service

Beach could have been cleaner. Lots of seaweed

Nice hotel with good food options. The hotel has a small private beach, a pool and beautiful areas to relax. The outdoor furniture is comfortable and the wicker pods are big enough for a couple to enjoy. Best of all was the friendly and accommodating staff. They were beyond awesome and made our stay exceptional. We mostly stayed on the property to relax, enjoy a few extraordinary massages and outstanding meals. The location was absolutely gorgeous.

If you like to walk, you will have to walk on the street to get to places nearby. There are no trails or sidewalks. The private beach was small and there are no adjacent beaches.

We felt safe, relaxed, and well-taken care of when we arrived. The staff goes above and beyond to make you feel happy and rested. The breakfast and dinner were excellent. The views from the room and dinner restaurant are breathtaking. The rental of the car was easy. Rupert even offered to drive us to the closest grocery store. We received an upgrade. Honestly, it felt like a small paradise. Thank you!

The waitress for dinner felt upset and was rushing through. She was not rude or anything, but she wanted to close the night and go home. Everything else was excellent.

The staff at the Sugar Mill were exceptional and very friendly- very accommodating. Sugar Mill Restaurant was fantastic- some of the best food we've ever had - Menu was diverse and well thought out. If you stay for a week, you won't eat the same food twice unless you really want to. If you want peace and quiet- this is the place to come - almost to the extreme level.

The property is very hilly and walking is difficult if your room is above the pool. Golf carts are available when available. The beach is very small and slopes toward the ocean. The beach/ocean, was too wavy to swim during our week stay. The staff does a good job of keeping the beach cleaned for the guests. The Tramonti bar, on the beach has limited drink selection (Not a full bar) and the staff do not wait on you if you stay on the beach- you'll have to get your own drinks. The pool is small but adequate. There is not a bar to speak of at the pool like advertised. It is simply a serve your self (On your honor) refrigerator with beer and soda, wine etc. It is not maintained daily and often will empty out. There are no servers at the pool either, you have to bring your own refreshments, use the on your honor fridge or walk to the bar to get a drink. The king sized beds are 2 twins pushed together- beware of the gap/hump down the middle and twin sheets on each bed. The room is nice, however, there is a small refrigerator in the room that has an an ice tray in the freezer but will not make ice and there is not an ice machine offered by the staff/management at the resort at least during our stay. If you plan on bringing your own liquor, make sure you ask for ice from the bartender. We found this out after 5 days of scrounging for ice. The hot water in the room will take 5 minutes to come in - so let the shower run and turn it to cold because the heat is not regulated very well and it may burn you. We got the impression that the resort caters to the restaurant as their star attraction rather than focusing on the rest of the resort Beware of the dreaded Roosters who will try and wake you up at 4:00 AM Ask a lot questions from the management and read the hotel guide book in you room if it your first time on the island/resort for things to do, transportation, supplies, tours, etc.

quiet and relaxing

beach was across road

The property was very beautiful overall. It’s a wonderful old stone building and it takes you back to another era. At a glance, rhe bedroom seemed inviting and very nicely decorated. The dining room had a very romantic feel to it which we thoroughly enjoyed.

We were completely disappointed with the bed in our room. It was two singles pulled together and the mattresses were lumpy and slanting. The pillows were of very poor quality. Overall the sleeping accommodation experience was very poor. We wanted to leave in the middle of the night because of the discomfort. We also felt that the room numbers could be much more visible. We had difficulty finding our room after coming home from dinner. Last but not least we didn’t have any warm or hot water after having left the water run for several minutes.

Staff was friendly ,food was excellent

Blankets and sheets were split in half would have preferred 1 blanket and one sheet