AmericInn by Wyndham Stillwater

My go to place to stay in Stillwater. Always look forward to it and haven’t been disappointed

Good place to stay always

Very well maintained and clean property.

To start off, it was hard to find this hotel, both my GPS and my Dad's GPS (who drove separately but stayed at same hotel) were directed to different areas not near this hotel when we put the address from the website for this hotel into our GPS devices. The room was okay, it had what we needed and seemed clean. There is no elevator for the second floor, so just prepare for that if you have a lot of bags. We had 5 people plus my dad in another room so it was a lot of bags to lug up the stairs, and since 3 of the people were kids, that was a little challenging. There was no vending on the 2nd floor, and there is no gym or even a water bottle filling station or drinking fountain. There is one ice machine on the first floor and vending there to purchase water. They had a decanter of water out by where the breakfast is served but it was not filtered drinking water and tasted off. The breakfast had no variety over our stay and was lackluster. The sausage was really low quality and did not have good flavor, the eggs were bland and barely tasted like eggs. I never have high standards for this kind of hotel, but usually we can find someone for everyone at a hotel like this and don't need to get breakfast elsewhere, that was not the case here. We got breakfast the 2nd day after seeing it was the exact same spread again. They did not have a fully stocked towel area by the pool. Both times we went to the pool there was 1 towel left. We had to ask for them to refill the towels, which they sort of did, bringing like 10 towels which which basically went down to just 4 towels after our group was done with them. They also asked that you leave the towels down there, which is weird because then you are dripping wet through the hotel. They have the cliche hotel pool towel blue stripe so they could easily be returned to the pool after a stay when they do laundry-- I don't recall having to leave my towel down there in any other hotel I have stayed at before this one. Positives: The pool and hot tub are a good size and temperature. Location is near lots of things and close enough to downtown Stillwater to get there pretty quickly. Clean rooms, nice staff.

Breakfast was lovely. The room was fresh and clean.

The toilet in our room was very low. Had trouble getting down and back up.

Positives: The pool and hot tub are a good size and temperature. Location is near lots of things and close enough to downtown Stillwater to get there pretty quickly. Clean rooms, nice staff.

To start off, it was hard to find this hotel, both my GPS and my Dad's GPS (who drove separately but stayed at same hotel) were directed to different areas not near this hotel when we put the address from the website for this hotel into our GPS devices. The room was okay, it had what we needed and seemed clean. There is no elevator for the second floor, so just prepare for that if you have a lot of bags. We had 5 people plus my dad in another room so it was a lot of bags to lug up the stairs, and since 3 of the people were kids, that was a little challenging. There was no vending on the 2nd floor, and there is no gym or even a water bottle filling station or drinking fountain. There is one ice machine on the first floor and vending there to purchase water. They had a decanter of water out by where the breakfast is served but it was not filtered drinking water and tasted off. The breakfast had no variety over our stay and was lackluster. The sausage was really low quality and did not have good flavor, the eggs were bland and barely tasted like eggs. I never have high standards for this kind of hotel, but usually we can find someone for everyone at a hotel like this and don't need to get breakfast elsewhere, that was not the case here. We got breakfast the 2nd day after seeing it was the exact same spread again. They did not have a fully stocked towel area by the pool. Both times we went to the pool there was 1 towel left. We had to ask for them to refill the towels, which they sort of did, bringing like 10 towels which which basically went down to just 4 towels after our group was done with them. They also asked that you leave the towels down there, which is weird because then you are dripping wet through the hotel. They have the cliche hotel pool towel blue stripe so they could easily be returned to the pool after a stay when they do laundry-- I don't recall having to leave my towel down there in any other hotel I have stayed at before this one.

Paid for a mistaken booking. Thought I had booked the Hudson property, and only found out when getting to Hudson.

Location was a bit off the beaten path

There is no elevator and my wife couldn’t do the stairs. We were offered a room on the first floor but was two queen beds instead of a king. The first room had an issue with the door that couldn’t be opened, so then had to get our third room. The room was quiet but we passed on breakfast. The coffee we threw out as well.