I was somewhat worried, reading some of the reviews about this property, and the negative experiences people had. Our experience was wonderful, and it’s my impression that many of the people with bad experiences come from a place of entitlement and this dampens their experience. Please see my review below:
Arrival & Check-In
From the moment we arrived, the experience felt special. We were greeted with beautiful handmade leis, which immediately set the tone for the stay. Roberto at the front desk was exceptionally kind and welcoming—he thoroughly explained the resort amenities and generously upgraded us to a partial ocean view room. Check-in was seamless, relaxed, and genuinely warm.
Bell Services
Ken, our bellman, was wonderful. He delivered our bags promptly, was extremely friendly, and even offered to get ice for us. These small gestures made a big difference and reflected the consistently thoughtful service throughout the resort.
Housekeeping
The housekeeping team was fantastic. Every day they swept the hardwood floors to remove sand, refreshed towels, and kept the room spotless. While there was no turndown service, their attention to detail and consistency really stood out, and the room always felt immaculate when we returned.
The Property, Beach & Location
The property itself is absolutely stunning. The beach access was a major highlight—guests are provided complimentary towels, umbrellas and two lounge chairs, which made beach days effortless and relaxing. The Burger Shack offering takeout that you can bring down to the beach was incredibly convenient and veggie burgers and shakes were delicious!
Ocean conditions varied during our stay (December): one day was calm and perfect for swimming, while other days had stronger waves. On one of our swims, we were lucky enough to see a sea turtle glide right past us—an unforgettable experience.
The location is excellent—just a scenic walk to Kapalua Bay via a beautiful coastal trail. The resort also neighbors the Montage, which is a great place to grab drinks or visit the spa.
An especially convenient perk of the location is the nearby Honolulu Market, located just steps from the resort. This market is incredibly well priced—comparable to Target or Walmart prices in town—which is rare for resort-adjacent shopping in Maui. They sell everything you might need: beer and wine, coffee, breakfast items, sandwiches, Dole Whip, snacks, beach supplies, and souvenirs. We highly recommend buying alcohol and snacks here to stock your room during your stay—it’s convenient, affordable, and well stocked.
Dining Experiences
Banyan Tree Restaurant:
We dined here twice and it quickly became our favorite. The Mai Tais were the best we had on the island (significantly better than the famously hyped Monkeypod). The food was delicious, the service was excellent, and the ocean views were stunning. Highly recommend the Maui onion dip with their fresh bread. The wine selection was also outstanding. Our server both nights, Marissa, was wonderful.
Sushi Bar & Patio Wine:
We also enjoyed the sushi bar and had wine on the patio—both were very good and made for relaxing, enjoyable evenings.
Luau Experience
The luau had several positives:
• Open bar with Moët, cocktails, wine, and beer
• Lei greeting upon arrival
• Complimentary photo opportunity
• A show that told a meaningful story of Hawaiian culture
• Food that was fairly good
However, there were notable downsides. Because the luau is indoors, the excitement of the fire dancing was limited—they couldn’t throw flames, which diminished the impact. There were also relatively few dancers, making the performance feel smaller and slower than other luaus we’ve attended. Additionally, the vegetarian option was simply seasoned tofu, which was disappointing given the $250 price point. Overall, the luau was below average in both experience and food. I would recommend going off site for a luau.
Pool & Oasis Daybed Experience
Booking an Oasis daybed was one of our favorite parts of the trip. From 11 a.m. to 5 p.m., we had attentive food and beverage service, a 10% discount on food, and $40 off sparkling wine bottles (including Prosecco), which made it an incredible value and a lot of fun by the pool.
While there was some pool maintenance during our stay, the resort handled it extremely well. We were informed ahead of time, and the work was scheduled so that only one of the three pools was affected at any given time. The pools were never overly crowded or noisy.
Activities & Experiences
• E-Bike Tour: We did the e-bike tour with Allison, who was absolutely wonderful—patient, kind, and incredibly knowledgeable about the coastline, wildlife, and Hawaiian history. This tour is a 10/10 and a must-do.
• Lei-Making Class: Free and very fun.
• Stars & S’mores: A lovely evening event where we made s’mores and met other couples.
• Friday Market: Featured local vendors, including a snorkel guide we later went out with who was excellent.
• Beach Cruisers: Complimentary bikes available to ride along the coastline—beautiful and such a thoughtful perk.
Anniversary Celebration & Special Touches
The Ritz-Carlton truly went above and beyond to celebrate our anniversary. Upon arrival, we found chocolate-covered strawberries and a handwritten note in our room. Midway through the trip, we received a bottle of wine and homemade banana bread with another thoughtful note. At the end of our stay, we were gifted a beautiful ukulele, a book on the history of Maui, a hand-carved wooden bookmark, and a Hawaii fridge magnet. These gestures were incredibly meaningful and exemplified exceptional hospitality.
Shopping & On-Site Staff
The retail staff throughout the resort were consistently friendly and helpful. There was also a sunglasses stand near the pool—an especially fun stop. The salesperson was wonderful and helped me choose a beautiful pair of pink Maui Jim sunglasses.
Spa
We did not use the spa on the property, primarily because there was not an outdoor/scenic co-ed relaxation pool area suitable for couples.
Concierge, Valet & Front Desk
The concierge team was incredibly accommodating and handled all of our excursions and bookings flawlessly. The front desk made both check-in and check-out effortless and was always happy to answer questions.
Valet service was outstanding. On two occasions, we requested our car at extremely early hours (around 4 a.m.), and it was always ready. We never waited more than 2–3 minutes after calling down. They frequently offered towels and water when we left for excursions and happily took used towels when we returned.
Room & Amenities
The room was more traditional in style—less modern and a bit dated—but still beautiful and very comfortable. The patio had a lovely ocean view. The bed was exceptionally comfortable, with down pillows and a duvet fully encased in a duvet cover. The room featured his-and-hers closets, two plush spa bathrobes, a Nespresso machine with pods replenished daily, a mini-fridge, room safe, and a six-drawer dresser. The Diptyque shampoo, conditioner, and body wash were a luxurious touch.
Overall Impression
This was an exceptional stay. While not everything was perfect (notably the luau), the warmth of the staff, attention to detail, anniversary celebrations, and overall hospitality truly set this Ritz-Carlton apart. We left feeling genuinely cared for and already look forward to returning.