McLays Guest House

This guest house was horrendous. The place if falling to bits

Would stay here again. Staff were lovely and helpful. The guest house is a bit rough around the edges but it does what it says on the tin. My bed was super comfy. The TV was a bit erratic. Tons of tea and coffee available. Breakfast was sufficient and tasty.

Staff were all really friendly, location was amazing. Very nice hotel.

This was a great guest house to stay almost a week in, very clean, comfortable and roomy. Really friendly staff, someone available 24/07. Good breakfast, a Scottish cooked breakfast tailored your way and plenty of cereal, continental pastries etc at the buffet table, tea, coffee and toast on tap! Nice terrace out front for smoking/tea or coffee in the sun on a relatively quiet street. Was not a negative for us but would like to point out as a tip that once you have navigated the steep street to get to the entrance there is then a very steep set of steps up to the front door, so not great for those less able-bodied than others or with large, heavy luggage or prams etc.

Dated

Hotel was great but close to bars and you could hear noise into the early hours. Didnt spoil my trip but could do for others

Right where we wanted to be and staff was friendly and helpful. It was clean and there was lots of room, but beds were uncomfortable and we heard the bass in the music at the nearby after-hours rave until after 3am Fri night/Sat morning.

Shared bathroom was in need of decoration and shower did not work. Plug missing from sink so had to wash with running water . Room was ok but landing and staircases in need of upgrading.... carpet filthy!

Dirty room, broken beds, unhygienic with spiders and cob webs all over the place will not be booking again

The mattress appeared to be devoid of any filling and had springs poking through. We awoke with spring marks on our bodies.. Waitress were nice and breakfast fine As to value for money. We are staying at accommodation I near Pitlochry which has a beautiful large bedroom with en-suite, a view and service far exceeding expectation. I would suggest that money needs to be spent urgently on upgrading as it is not fit for habitation