The Evergreen Hotel

Hot lovked out of the room for an hour while they tried to get us back in

The only negative was the hot tub jets were broken.

We returned to The Evergreen after having a very pleasant stay four nights prior. During our prior stay we got into the hot tub which was tepid at best. They looked into it and apparently the breaker on the heater tripped so they reset it and it slowly began to warm (huge tub, takes hours of which we didn't have). On our return we experienced the same. Makes you wonder if maybe they need a new heater? Given that it was 90 outside, no big deal but if I was here during the winter it'd be another story as the tub is very large and takes hours to heat.

Everything was very nice. Rooms and amenities were great! Lounge was short on good beers that weren't IPA type which many of us don't like! That was disappointing.... Enjoyed my stay overall!

We stayed in a King room with kitchenette which was super spacious. It was updated and very clean which is mostly what I seek in a hotel room. I thought the room was pricey for Idaho but considering the Best Western was even more, I guess this is the market for the area. My only gripe was that the shower door would not stay closed during my shower which was frustrating and the water pressure in the bathroom sinks was insanely low. But overall a good experience and not only would I return but I did a few days later when back in the area.

See below

Bathroom sink plugged entire stay. Told front desk clerk I who indicated they were aware and some one would fix same. At check out the maintence mgr was there and advised no one advised them. Secondly our tv remote didn’t work and again they were advised and nothing happened. Thirdly you had a boil water alert. There was nothing put out. My wife and I had coffee in our room. I found about this when I later went to the front desk to get some coffee. They and restaurant weren’t making coffee due to the unhealthy water. I asked why they hadn’t notified guests because we were drinking the water. The response was a shoulder shrug. This health scare wasn’t good for us as both elderly. We will be home in two days and will put this review on social media.

The Evergreen Hotel is always my first choice when staying in McCall. It is clean, smells nice, has nice staff and is conveniently located.

Hotel was very nice. Clean and friendly. Would stay here again.