Olde Amish Inn

Yikes… I knew it would be a resort for $75 but this was pretty awful. The bathroom was beyond disgusting. I would not have gotten in that nasty shower unless I was covered in mud. No bathroom fan, no shampoo, the soap was from another hotel, the towels were very worn and thin. There were hairs on the sink and dirt on the floor between the bathroom and bedroom. The “king size” bed was 2 twins pushed together that felt like you were sloshing in the ocean when you tried to move. There were brownish red stains on the underside of the comforter that was straight out of the 1980’s. Just really dated and gross all around. I’m not sure how it has a 7.2 rating, so here’s a review for you who think it’ll be fine based on that high score so you can make your own choice.

great overall

The only thing I had a problem with were the beds, they were rock hard. Felt like I was sleeping on a hard board. Everything else about the room was nice, I loved the hot water pressure, I had 2 mini fridges for some reason. Also, there was no telephone in room, and I did not see any free wifi password available, even though room was advertised with free wifi..I will stay here again

In town for a basketball tournament and didn’t want to pay over $200/night for us to just sleep there. Bathroom was the worst thing. Smelled like pee (possible shower curtain) and the shower head wouldn’t fully work but we made do. Beds were comfortable, AC working and Hot water. No bugs and decent sized room. Fridge and microwave provided. Would stay here again if in town if trying to save money.

I was pleasantly surprised by this property. The location is very good with regard to attractions in Amish country. Some of the reviews were bad, but at this price point I would give 5 stars. There are outstanding sunrise views to the east of the property. The family that run the property seemed very nice. The man that checked me in on Wednesday 6-11-25 gave me an east facing top floor room when I requested one.

It was clean and nicely decorated with a good size fridge. The room was ground level and parking was right outside our door. It is very convenient to many locations.

Property close to everything

The bed was shot. There was no coffee maker in room. There was no second key offered.when asked for made service we received clean towels and they emptied the trash.

The room is very dated. Bathroom faucet is very dirty. No coffee maker. We only stayed one night and moved to another hotel for the second night.

Clean and comfortable