The Atlantis Historic Inn

I so wanted to love this hotel but it was underwhelming, a bit tired, lacking in much atmosphere, and the staff, whilst polite, were not overly helpful or accommodating. We were also extremely annoyed to find out we had been booked on a room only basis when it had been made out to be on a bed and breakfast basis. This was completely misleading and the hotel staff were unhelpful and unwilling to do anything to make up for this issue. So we ate elsewhere. Our coastal room was large, clean and classically stylish - but looked out on a generator and had nearby dogs barking constantly from 6am - so book an ocean view to avoid this! The in-room fridge was in dire need of replacement as it was rusty and not somewhere to keep fresh food or drink. There were cracked tiles in the bathroom and our toilet seat was broken. These things are not reflective of the hotel prices and made for an overall disappointing stay. There are better places to stay nearby in my opinion with better amenities. The Atlantis needs a refurb and some love injected back into it as the location is stunning on the East Coast and it has a lot of history…It seemed to be a bit forgotten and unloved by its current owners…

Enjoyed the amazing ocean view and the hotel's antique ambiance,food and service.

The property is very nice and well maintained, very clean. Staff is polite and very helpful. The area is very picturesqu-e and clean. We had wonderful experience.

What a fantastic stay! Couldn’t get more Oceanside big great pool and pool side area perfect and steel drums and other music perfect volume and selection …room spacious super comfortable and ALL staff was fabulous made me feel pampered special and like family they care! Highly recommend and next visit I’ll be spending more time here! Food delicious also fruit punch the best!!! Can’t say enough good go visit enjoy for yourselves!!

Such an amazing small hotel. Stunning location, breath-taking views. The staff were wonderful and the food was excellent.

Right on the coast. Large rooms that are not boring/generic. Nice common areas. Numerous historic pictures on the walls. Friendly staff. Nice welcome drink and nice dinner & breakfast. Will definitely come back.

staff friendly, great location and food was very nice and all at a fair price

nothing all good

Staff were amazing here. The views are lovely on this quieter side of the Island and the Historical Inn is very interesting.

Loved it! The best option for someone who wants to stay on the east side of the island. So close to the beach & Soup bowl. The staff were so welcoming and accommodating. The room was beautiful, and we got an ocean side view which was amazing to wake up to every morning