Faraway Sag Harbor

I have stayed there multiple times and specifically for the past 2 years Fourth of July weekends. Although all the public spaces are very pretty and it looks over the water with a decent selection of food we have unfortunately had clothing stolen from our room on both stays the day we were checking out. I thought I was going crazy when it first happened as an entire new dress abd shoes went missing and then it just happened again to my husband who had custom monogrammed shirts that were not in his bag when he got home. They were not in lost and found and never found. They also changed our room from a garden suite to a lesser room without asking when we added a day to our stay ahead of arrival. It is a cute place but they have staffing issues clearly.

Breakfast was exceptional in presentation, taste and value. Staff members were attentive and personable.

Nothing worth mentioning.

Everything. Very great and comfortable room, kind service.

It’s a bit on the pricey side…

Really beautiful and clean property that is very convenient and great amenities.

We loved our first visit to Sag Harbor and Baron’s Cove was the perfect boutique hotel. Thank you for taking great care of us! The accommodations were charming, comfortable, centrally located, and we absolutely enjoyed the amazing views! Thank you to Anthony as well for great hospitality. Until next time..cheers!

The property is beautiful and conveniently located. Staff are kind, polite and helpful. Cleanliness mostly was fine. The shower floor is a concrete looking stone which is hard to see if it's cleaned and there was hair still on the drain.

We loved the location, near the water and walking distance to the village the pool was wonderful too, and the Caesar salad at the pool was delicious

Nothing

My husband and i travel from Az to celebrate our 25th anniversary! Hotel was absolutely beautiful, clean comfortable and staff was super friendly. Would definitely recommend and will be staying again!

Great location in the heart of town Walk to everything Amazing breakfast too

Room had ants, staff handled it terribly. No more rooms to accommodate, originally was having trouble to give us our money back. Never assisted to find a new surrounding place because it was 1030 in the evening. Never sent anyone to check the room or help us with our luggage. We had ants on is and our belongings. Never followed up the next day until I called them. Such a disappointment, went last year and had the best time.