Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel

We just had our fifth stay at the Anchor Inn. It's clean, quiet, and ideally located within walking distance of downtown. Those under the age of eighteen are not allowed to stay in the main hotel, which is a definite plus for us. Breakfast is included and made to order. It's something to consider with the price of eating on the island. My wife says the rooms are beautifully appointed. I won't stay anywhere else for fear of her being disappointed.

Great stay! Room was well appointed and clean, delicious breakfast and great communication from host before and during our stay. Will definitely return!

We loved the Anchor Inn. It was a perfect location for walking into town but far enough away that you didn’t get all the noise at night. We had a wonderful breakfast on the porch each morning and the staff was friendly and helpful. The small deck off of our room was great for sitting and reading and we loved our room. A comfortable bed awaited us each night and turn down service left us a little treat each night on the nightstand.

We loved everything about this place.

Anchor Inn Boutique was an absolute gem in Put-In-Bay. Our room was spotless and beautifully decorated, creating a cozy and welcoming atmosphere. The staff went above and beyond—friendly, helpful, and always available with a smile. And the breakfast? Truly to die for—delicious, fresh, and clearly made with care. We couldn’t have asked for a better place to stay. Highly recommend!

Beautifully maintained and the staff was extremely friendly and helpful. Breakfast was outstanding!

Liked everything

This was our second visit to the Anchor Inn. We are now making it an annual trip. The entire experience is great. The rooms are clean and comfortable with an evening treat and black out curtains every night. The breakfast in the morning is nothing short of impressive. From the European style continental breakfast set out to the custom order from the menu and then the features! The owner is so nice. And the staff is great too! Top notch! Thanks again!

Great place to stay, A+++++±+

The location is wonderful! the room as beautiful, the breakfast delicious and the staff was friendly. The nicest place we have stayed at on the Island. It is a little pricey, but I guess you get what you pay for.

This place is amazing. Super close location to all the bars and restaurants. Very clean, modern amenities in the rooms. Balconies. easy to check in. Turn down service. The breakfast is incredible. So much variety and cooked to order food as well (Included). Great service as well!