The Coco, The Edgartown Collection

Property was great and the breakfast was fantastic. The walls are ridiculously thin - we could hear everything from the neighbouring rooms at all hours of the night which made our stay not as pleasant as it could have been.

Location was exceptional. Front gardens were spectacular. Restaurant L’Etouile is on main floor. Awesome bar! Unfortunately, our room, No. 4 on 2nd floor sits above the restaurant. Music blared until 1:50 am. Alex, the manager of Coco was terrific regarding my middle of midnight text. I suggest their sister hotel, The Sydney, as it is newly built and doesn’t have all the issues that an antique building has, such as heating and cooling noise. Also, their Continental breakfast was sub-par. Btw) I was disappointed for $750.00 a night, they could have a few higher end accessories, such as a functional iron, and a $20.00 blow dryer. The location is def what you pay for in this hotel…

Perfect location close to lots of restaurants and shopping. Beautiful hotel with great decor and friendly staff.

Nothing. It was perfect!

the perfect place to stay!

We absolutely loved the hotel and our stay and the team could not be nicer. One issue was that we were directly above the restaurant so it was noisy til 10pm..... I have a 4 year old so that was challenging. However the hotel offered to move us immediately to one of their other properties however my daughter refused to move as she said it was " the most beautiful room she had even been in and she couldn't leave her pink fishes (the gorgeous wallpaper)" (fierce words for someone who's mom designs hotels for a living ) so we stayed and had a wonderful stay and would stay hear again. Alex, Ellen and the team are just so wonderful and helpful - they capture the spirit of the island and vacation in this magical little place.

This place depends greatly on the room you get. I was on first floor above restaurant (room 1) and it was really loud.

Great location

Staff MIA when raised concerns. Extremely noisy with paper thin walls and doors and door to room bangs every time someone opens front door of building. Tiny bathroom barely can move in there. Air conditioning malfunctioning way too cold during day then would turn off often at night.

Great location, comfy room, lovely breakfast. Loved the water/coffee/tea bar.

Bit pricey