Stay Realm Logo

Discover

Hotels

Settings

Currency
Language
Loading...
9.2 / 10 Guest Rating

Sunset Beach Hotel

35 Shore Rd, Shelter Island, New York, 11965, Shelter Island, US

Sunset Beach Hotel - main view

About the Property

Convenient Amenities
Indulge in complimentary wireless internet, concierge services, and even a babysitting option at a surcharge. The hotel also offers on-site shopping and wedding services for your convenience.

Delicious Dining Options
Savor a meal at the hotel's restaurant or grab a snack at the snack bar/deli. Unwind with a drink at the bar/lounge or opt for a to-go breakfast available daily for a fee.

Luxurious Accommodations
Relax in one of the 20 guestrooms with minibars and Smart TVs. Sink into comfort with down comforters and Frette Italian sheets, and enjoy amenities like complimentary wireless internet and designer toiletries in the private bathrooms.

Unwind at Sunset Beach Hotel, where luxury meets convenience and steps away from the beach. Book your stay now for a memorable experience.

Facilities & Amenities

Front entrance ramp
Electric car charging station
Free WiFi
Luggage storage
Concierge service
Wheelchair accessible
Shopping on site
Breakfast available (surcharge)
Safe-deposit box at front desk
Front desk (limited hours)

Important Information

Check-in & Out

Check-in
Check-out11:00 AM

Property Notes

Guests can access their rooms with a mobile device.

Check Room Availability

1 night · 2 adults

No rooms available

We couldn't find any available rooms for these dates and guests. Try adjusting your search criteria.

Guest Reviews

9.2
Exceptional11 verified reviews

Categories

Cleanliness9.6
Location9.8
Service9.2
Facilities9.0
Value for money8.9
Comfort9.5

Select topics to read reviews

D
Darlene
Verified booking
family
Standard Room
Stayed in Sep 5, 2024

"Good"

4.0

There were many small things that added up, leaving us less than satisfied.

Helpful?
L
Leeza
Verified booking
Standard Room
Stayed in Aug 20, 2024

"Exceptional"

10.0

The location and room were great for a beach hotel. No room service and no coffee in the room The restaurant opens late and doesn’t serve breakfast. Otherwise amazing.

Helpful?
C
Charlie
Verified booking
Standard Room
Stayed in Aug 11, 2024

"Exceptional"

10.0

This is an amazingly fun place to spend a few days with lots if options to entertain yourself in beautiful surroundings. what a great team they have. be back next year.

Helpful?
D
David
Verified booking
Standard Room
Stayed in Jul 21, 2024

"Good"

6.0

Needs some tender loving care , Rooms are feeling Jaded, Paint, door refurbishment ,and the terraces need floors replaced and repaired Has great bones , but plenty of money needs to be made available after the season, to ensure all the work in the winter gets completed…-It can either be maintained and be a place to go or be a major disappointment…. Up to management

Helpful?
E
emma rajkovic
Verified booking
Standard Room
Stayed in Jul 14, 2024

"Exceptional"

10.0

It's just a lovely low key chic place for relaxing. An antidote to the Hamptons

Helpful?
C
Christopher
Verified booking
Standard Room
Stayed in Jul 13, 2024

"Exceptional"

10.0

The room was very clean without any issues. Front desk was super friendly and catered to my needs.

Helpful?
M
Mariola
Verified booking
Standard Room
Stayed in Jul 11, 2024

"Perfect Escape from NYC"

8.0

The hotel is one of a kind. Beautifully located just across from the beach in a quiet area. Very little, practically zero traffic. The room was very comfortable. All rooms are overlooking the bay. The beach was quiet and the water amazing for swimming. The personnel was kind and helpful. We even had ice delivered to the beach by the Ice Man :) There are several restaurants within a short drive. I recommend Commander Cody’s Fish Market (casual, great seafood). We were there on Tuesday and the bar and restaurant are closed on Tuesdays. There is more going on between Thursday and Saturday, we were told. Overall, an amazing five star experience.

Helpful?
S
Saurabh
Verified booking
Standard Room
Stayed in Jun 27, 2024

"Exceptional"

10.0

Extremely friendly staff, great place for a weekend getaway

Helpful?
P
Patrick
Verified booking
family_with_children
Standard Room
Stayed in Jun 24, 2024

"Exceptional"

10.0

They have a great staff who are very helpful.

Helpful?
C
Christina
Verified booking
friends
Standard Room
Stayed in Jun 16, 2024

"Excellent"

8.0

Love the Saint Tropez vibe and the retro decor. Beautiful location right on the beach for a stunning sunset, amazing seafood, fun and lively atmosphere.

Helpful?
1
2