Club Comanche Hotel, St. Croix

Location

This review is written for a friend who is unable to write the review. This hotel apparently has fallen on hard times. My friend said that when arrived at the hotel. There was an note on the door advising her to call a number and they told her she can pick up the key from desk . The staff had gone home. She is physically challenged and she is on oxygen. The key to the room for a second floor room. There were no first floor rooms open for occupancy! The elevator was broken. She could not stay at the hotel. She tried days before arriving to contact someone to request a first floor room. She tried for days to get someone on the phone. No one picked up. Please do not stay at this hotel unless you willing to take a chance.

This place is a beautiful although slightly run down historic hotel in a perfect location. The run down part just adds to the charm. It is clean, the staff literally can not be better (Shameka sp? is just the best). We will return to St. Croix annually and will stay only one place.

Check in process is poor and non-personal. Room access is subject to unwanted guests

There was a hidden charge of $35.00 of electricity that I dient expected to have during my stay.

The pool was green. There was too much noise. The area was nice with lots of restaurants.

The room was clean and well air conditioned. it is an old hotel that needs quite a bit of work. Staff was friendly, pool was out of service. checking in was a challenge. get ready to wake up bright and early (0330 - 0500). The chickens start crowing at 3:30 am right outside the window. I was on business so didn't spend much time there, but definitely would not be my first choice for a vacation rental.

Everything was nice

Absolutely do not stay here!!!! The place is a complete disaster. The pool is empty and are is full of debris. Has apparently never been properly renovated following hurricane damage. The walls and structure are cracked and unrepaired. Otherwise, it would have a beautiful location and views, which are totally ruined by the poor condition of the property. Mattresses in rooms also appear to have stains from prior bedbug infestation.

Worse hotel experience I have ever had. First there was no Air Conditioning and we sweated all night. There were holes in the ceiling and floor. The fire alarm system battery was failing and there was chirping all night. Only positive was that the ladies that worked there were very friendly, they simply had their hands tied. It made a trip in paradise a waste of money.