Club Comanche Hotel, St. Croix

If only I could submit photos of the ACTUAL property you will see! Please do yourself a favor and DO NOT BOOK THIS ROOM!!! Go to the Caravelle or Kings Christian. The rooms have inches of dust, the windows don’t close allowing all kinds of bugs and insects in, the floor boards move under your feet making you feel like you could fall through the floor at any moment, there’s ROACHES, the TV in my room didn’t work, theres no on site restaurant or bar (like they say in the comments), the pool is a dead man’s zone, I showered with my shoes on until I saw a roach then I zipped my suitcase up and called EXPEDIA for my refund, which they kindly gave me. Then I walked my but right to Caravelle and received the absolute best service ever!! Please do not stay here save yourself the stress! EVEN THE LOCALS WILL SAY “WHY DID YOU STAY THERE???!!!”

The building is in utter disrepair. Three of us traveled for work and our female coworker was in a room where the windows could not be closed. The tv’s didn’t work and the pool is open and empty against code compliance. One room had wooden floors with large gaps between the floor boards. Refund was requested as we had to move to a different hotel.

The hours of staff on site was 9-11am. Horrible. 1st room had mold, holes in wall & not enough towels. Ut was on the 3rd level. No hallway lighting. It was dark & dank. I called the numbers listed, without response. I cried. I was moved on rhe bext morning, but my disposition had already been sullied.

Check in was a little different. The was nobody at the front desk. we had to call and get a code to the door and get our key. Pool was not filled Room was not cleaned properly, Old soda and water bottles underneath the bed. Staff had to bring us towels as they were not left after "said cleaning"

It was a wonderful experience to stay in a hotel built in 1756. It would be a great experience to try the elevator so I hope it gets restored and It wood save from using the stairs if you have problems. Wonderful location great beach and great food. We wish we could have stayed longer.

By far one of the oldest and historic hotels if you appreciate all things wood and Grand architecture beautiful 50 ft wide boat Chandelier and the common space Hotel also brags huge swimming pool beautiful sunset scenes and boardwalk close by surrounded by plenty of shopping and restaurants can I say more

First to all, I get the “best” room with sea sight with a great bed. Everything start when I trying to close curtains got broken once, toilet it doesn’t work, bathroom dirty, damage and torn towels and overall service it was awful.

Property is not as advertised. They do not have Continental Breakfast or a usable swimming pool. The headboard on the bed was broken making it impossible to sit up in bed to watch TV or read. The towels were torn and the curtains were damaged and would not close properly. The coffee pot had the wrong carafe so it was necessary to hold it up against the filter basket or it would overflow.Once the coffee was made, I discovered there were no cups. It is very noisy being and old building. (Not their fault). Also, the roosters start crowing outside the window at 3:00AM. (Also not their fault). I stayed 2 nights but never saw an employee of the hotel. The office hours are 9:30AM to 11:30AM and I was there on business, leaving at 8:00AM and returning after 5:00PM. I have visited this area before, staying at other hotels which I found much nicer and much more reasonable even during the busy season. This hotel is extremely overpriced which explains why it was one of the few choices available on short notice. I have been traveling for business weekly, for almost 40 years and found this to be one of the most disappointing hotels I've ever stayed in.

To be fair, everything is pretty difficult, unreliable, and run down on St. Croix. Its obvious this hotel used to be really hopping and cool, but covid has changed things. Check in is kind of difficult, requiring a call to an "emergency number." The building is very old (ca 1753), so it is not well insulated or modern. Be aware, there seems to be no hot water, and local roosters make noise all day and night...and are very loud. The power went out twice while we were there, which makes for very hot rooms. It is in a great location, but that's about it.

Book at your own risk! I feel like this place is a scam… My wife and I from Las Vegas booked a suite for our honeymoon with a King bed and couch. However the room we received is 2 double beds and 5 lounge chairs. This is not what we booked or expected. The room is filthy and looks like it hasnt been cleaned in years. There’s a boarded up window and exposed hole where the AC unit drains right over the bed. All furniture looks and feels dirty. The ceiling fans have inches of dust on them. We are not staying here not even one night, we don’t feel comfortable staying here. When we called the office about the bed mix up he said “I don’t know why this keeps happening”. The owner came by and said they couldn’t do anything until the next day and even then a room switch wasn’t guaranteed. For the amount of money they are asking it absolutely doesn’t add up. When we tried to notify the owner that we wouldn’t be staying and need to cancel and dispute, he started sending us straight to voicemail so we started a claim with Expedia to at least get the ball rolling. This was a devastating experience.