Montauk Yacht Club

Endless bass line at 2am (don’t stay in rooms closest to restaurant. The same restaurant that served 2 day old expired caviar which we realized after we were done, served with a metal spoon. Don’t ask people to spend that kind of money and not have the right spoon. 12 mins for a coffee order. The “market” ran out of milk to make coffee. Service is all international staff here for summer really trying their very best. The best part is don’t bring snacks or crack open a soda and try to drink it in the dark. Ants. Everywhere. Even in my pants and all over a sprite can. It’s trying hard to be the instagram image alas, this will not ever be st Barts. I miss old montauk.

Wonderful property !

I loved everything

Very relaxed stay with the family. The setting is amazing. We had a family cottage with a sea view. The staff were great and the place has a lot of space along the waterfront. You pay $100 cover a day for bikes pool paddle boards and courtesy car into town (not back) which is worth it if you are using it all.

I have come here for a while and is the best place to stay in mtk. A little outside of the main areas but you can’t beat the pool.

My family takes our annual summer boat trip to MYC year. This year we arrived in July 2025 As always the trip is super special and we build fabulous memories - the team and staff are accommodating, friendly and vey professional. This year was especially great, over the past several years we got to know Luka, pool attendant very well, we had understood he might not be back this summer- the whole family was disappointed- we we arrived at the pool and he was there are trip went from great to outstanding!!! We also met many other fabulous staff members: To name a few of the wonderful people: Ana L - wait staff, Chateau- beautiful and warm!, Shiloh and Marina at the bar! Ivan at the pool! Vitoria in the shop!! And so many more- the hotel is spotless, the dock is fun and safe, and the food is outstanding! We will be back again and again!

Great service, beautiful restaurant, great food, and happy to see our friend Luka, our favorite pool attendant!!!!!!

The Montauk Yacht Club strikes a perfect balance between luxury and the laid-back vibe Montauk is famous for. The rooms are large (especially as compared to other hotels in the area) and so comfortable. The views from the pool and the beach are breathtaking. It is truly the perfect place to relax and to also enjoy the incredible amenities offered by the hotel, many of which were included with the stay. From yoga to bike riding to a ride on the fabulous electric boat, everything the hotel offers is done with the highest level of thought and attention to detail. If you happen to be there on a Thursday evening, be sure to have a drink at the bar and enjoy the reggae band. Each and every member of the hotel staff was engaging, helpful and a pleasure to deal with. I booked our next stay before we left!

Very nice restaurant.

Location, cleanliness and the vibe

Restaurant over priced for the meals and the portions in particular!