Mill House Inn

Spent my birthday here after arriving from Australia. Felt like I was in a movie and one of my wishes had come true staying in an historic Inn in the Hamptons. The Inn and grounds are beautiful and we were completely spoilt by Kelli who was inconspicuous yet so attentive to our questions and requests. The suite was stunning and the bed and bedding were exceptionally comfy and luxe. We felt like we had the place to ourselves and had afternoon cocktails on the porch watching the sunset and the windmill before heading to a beautiful restaurant in Sag Harbour for dinner.

We could not make the plug work in the tub so missed out on that but the fireplace and bed made up for it!

Breakfast was such a delight every morning. It was delicious and delivered hot and fresh the first morning to our room.The second morning we were able to have a beautiful breakfast outside in the garden. Our third and last morning they went above and beyond, having it packaged &prepared early for us to get on the road. The location was so pretty and central to everything. All the staff was welcoming, knowledgeable, and professional.

Really there wasn’t anything to complain about. We had a wonderful room with everything we needed. It was so easy to communicate with the staff and they met all our needs.

The Mill House Inn is pure heaven. It is beautiful, comforting, bright and simply lovely. The staff is OUTSTANDING with their genuine care and concern. We feel like we found new friends in Dawn and Kelli. They were SO helpful with shopping ideas, sightseeing trips and a host of other info! I have life threatening food allergies which was addressed every night as I ordered our breakfast for the following morning. The menu and food are superb! We had a slight issue with our room and Kenny the GM upgraded us to a beautiful suite. I hurt my back pretty badly prior to our trip and our original room was on the third floor which was quite cumbersome for me. It was a lovely cozy smaller room, with a dormered ceiling. It was a tad confining for a tall woman with a bad back! Upon Kenny learning all of this, (in addition we were celebrating our 25th wedding anniversary) he most generously upgraded us to a larger 2nd floor suite that was more comfortable for us with my situation! We were beyond shocked but so very appreciative! We met the owner Sylvia and she concurred they wanted us to be comfortable and were pleased they had a suite open to offer us. What truly wonderful people! We were sad to leave and can’t wait to go back. But what wonderful memories we have! We will always remember our 25th anniversary with happy hearts.💝

The ambiance and the service were excellent. They really went out of their way to be of service yet stayed out of the way so you felt like you were the only ones there. Perfect!

Beautiful Inn, friendly staff. Had a great time in gorgeous East Hampton!

The Inn was wonderful but they have gotten a little COVID wacky. You had to have breakfast in your room as an example and they don’t supply a table.

MHI is a wonderful, warm inn situated in the heart of East Hampton. The owners and staff are amazing and treat you like family (in the best ways!). Breakfasts are amazing and access to village and town beaches make it invaluable during the season. Definitely will come back!

false advertisement and terrible service

Lovely stay, had an issue with air and we were given another room immediately. Very comfy and cozy!

We had the most amazing time at the Mill House Inn! It was our first time to the Hamptons and it did not disappoint. Our room was cozy, clean, and the bed was super comfortable. Kenny was wonderful with restaurant recommendations and he even called us 2 weeks before our stay to alert us of the status of things with Covid. Dawn was a delight, attentively catering to our snack/breakfast needs. We absolutely loved it and can’t wait to return to the Mill House Inn. Thanks for making it such an awesome experience!