Mill House Inn

The warm welcome, the friendly and helpful personnel (thank you, Dawn, for your help with restaurant reservations and recommendations), the cosy location and the breakfast made our vacation so much better. If we go back to the Hamptons, we’re coming back to the Mill House Inn.

First of all we liked the set-up of the Inn, in a nice garden. The house has an ancient vibe and breaths a warmhearted spirit. The staff are very friendly. The breakfast in very yummy and has just something different than the usual. All day availability of cold and warm drinks and snacks, including the famous cookies. The bedroom is small but extremely cosy, with the surplus of an "open" fire place.

I would like to have a bigger closet to store the cloths, but thats not a big issue.

Fireplace bed bathroom soaking tub shower.. I didn’t want to leave

That I couldn’t stay longer! Every thing was perfect!

Only location was good.

Breakfast was more than horrible, they don’t clean rooms, stuff was weird, especially older woman.

Astounding service, great rooms, clean, cozy, warm and homey.

Location is close to the town. House looks like a typical country style

This was a same day reservation for us. The moment the reservation went in we received a call from a lady that we had to check in bc she had to leave… it was well before 3:00p. She was not very friendly. She told us we had to put breakfast order in writing asap for us to get breakfast next am, and to make sure we check out on time bc the late checkout rm was taken. You are only allowed half hr on the dining room table. Bathroom incredibly small. Hard to sleep, bed squeaks and you could hear everything inside and outside the house. The carpet was disgustingly dirty/stained … luckily it was only one night. We had breakfast somewhere else. We paid close to $800 for one night! Not worth the $$$, would not recommend. The night before we stayed at The Baker House, amazing place!

Really friendly staff who helped us when our booking with original hotel fell through. When they heard of our situation we got a free upgrade on the room as we were staying for my birthday & honeymoon.