The Edgartown Inn, The Edgartown Collection

Beautiful hotel and great service!

Neusa was the best Innkeeper ever. She was kind, welcoming, and made us feel like we were long-lost friends. Rooms are clean. Inn is very convenient. And the continental breakfast was nothing short of gourmet. We plan to come again!

Location, homey feel

Did not clean the room

Everything! We were able to experience two different rooms because we had to add an extra night last minute and though both were in different floors and views they were very nicely appointed, clean and spacious. We loved the breakfast, fire pit, location and whole vibe of the place. The staff could not have been more helpful. Will definitely stay here again!

Nothing!

Staying at the Edgartown Inn feels like coming home. The staff are warm and professional, and do everything they can to make your stay enjoyable. While the old decor of the Inn was full of history and antiques, the new renovations are well-done and provide a peaceful and cozy update to this historic gem of an inn. The rooms are comfortable, the breakfast is delicious, and the warm chocolate chip cookies are not to be missed! We thoroughly enjoyed our stay and highly recommend this inn for visitors to Martha's Vineyard.

Our second stay at the Edgartown Inn and we were even impressed than the last. The property is in an excellent location which makes for easy walkability. The staff (Neusa) were wonderful and the breakfast will undoubtedly exceed your expectations. We did hear another guest complain about the room between rooms / floors - but I would imagine they’re not typical BnB customers. Thanks again for a wonderful stay.