Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel

If you're looking for the perfect place to stay in Put-in-Bay, look no further than the Anchor Inn! This was our second stay, and somehow it was even better than the first. The rooms are absolutely gorgeous—beautifully decorated, and spotless. The location is perfect, within walking distance of everything, yet peaceful and relaxing. The breakfast alone is worth the stay! Every morning features an incredible made-to-order breakfast with delicious daily specials, along with an assortment of fresh meats, cheeses, fruit, and other options. It's far beyond the typical hotel breakfast and truly starts your day off right. What makes the Anchor Inn truly exceptional, however, is the hospitality. Paul, the curator and chef, is one of the kindest and most genuine people you'll ever meet. During our stay, we experienced a personal emergency and had to leave unexpectedly. Even after hours, Paul came back to the inn to help facilitate the return of our golf cart, arrange taxis, and assist us with our luggage. His compassion, professionalism, and willingness to go above and beyond turned a stressful situation into one that was completely manageable. Service like that is rare, and it's the reason we will continue coming back. The Anchor Inn isn't just a place to stay—it's a place where you're treated like family. We absolutely love Paul and cannot recommend this beautiful boutique hotel highly enough. Five stars all the way!

Awesome breakfast and place to stay. Paul and staff are wonderful.

Friendly staff, excellent breakfast & overall ambiance of the venue.

The mattress springs were creeky. The uncomfortable mattress left me with sore spots in back and hips.

the breakfasts were great

a longer stay

Breakfast was the icing on the cake. My husband ate his fair share! Thank you, Paul. I very much liked the king-sized beds and the attention to detail - turning on the lights and closing the blinds for us every night, was well received.

N/A

Along with being a wonderful owner, Paul served up excellent meals every morning! One morning I had the spinach quiche and it was fabulous. The third morning I had the maple biscuits and sausage gravy and that's not normally something that I will eat. However! I'm glad I ordered it-I don't regret it! They always put out wonderful selection of fresh fruits, fresh cheeses, even pate! I just can't say enough about our experience. I can't wait to return! I'm very high maintenance and my entire stay exceeded all expectations. Stunning home. Thank you for having us.

Excellent costumer service

Very clean, and cozy room. The hotel was just off the main area so it was a close walk to all the bars and restaurants. Staff was friendly and the breakfast was great with multiple options for made to order dishes.

We had a wonderful time at the Anchor Inn! The host was very personable and cooked fantastic breakfasts each morning. Good parking, great location, and beautiful rooms. Looking forward to our next visit.