The Carroll Villa Hotel

The room we stayed in was perfect for our needs. It was on the smaller side, but we knew that going in, and saved some money by staying in room 18. The bathroom was new, clean and spacious with a heated floor which was a nice touch. The bedroom was cozy, clean and well appointed. The location of this property is perfect for either beach or walking the shops and restaurants. Breakfast at the mad batter located on the first floor of the property was delicious with tremendous portions. We were provided with a $30 voucher each day, which covered the cost of breakfast for 2. Staff was friendly and helpful. Can’t wait to stay again.

We had a fantastic stay at the Carroll Villa in mid December 2026–our fourth or fifth stay over as many years in summer and winter. The staff and accommodations are great on all counts—the friendly service and feel of a family owned boutique, with the amenities and location equal to any competitors in the area. The restaurant being on location (and extremely popular in its own right, with excellent breakfast/bar/music) makes it extremely convenient for families. A very unique place among the inns in Cape May, with a fittingly long track record.

Our stay was perfect. The room was so clean and beautiful. We loved the location and all staff were so cordial and helpful. 10/10!

Location is perfect for a downtown experience….so close to everything. Staff is super friendly. Beds are very nice and the stay was fantastic. Spent an hour or so in the bar area and had a couple of drinks while listening to live music. Would highly recommend this property. Thumbs way up!

We had a wonderful fall stay at this lovely inn. So close to everything, the location is perfect. The beach is steps away and the shopping and dining options are plentiful. We were treated exceptionally well by manager Pam, Linda at the front desk, and the housekeeping staff, who went above and beyond. Our two room suite was adorable and very clean, the bed was comfortable and the voucher for breakfast was great. The Mad Batter is THE place for a great breakfast or lunch. All in all, I’d give this quaint hotel 5 stars and highly recommend it! Thank you to everyone at the Carroll Villa Hotel for a memorable stay!

A great experience service was great and the restaurant was great! They provide veterans world class service! Looking forward to visit again.

Room was spacious, clean and really nice. Bathroom was modern and had a heated floor, which was great! Staff are friendly and a pleasure to deal with. Restaurant and bar downstairs (The Madd Batter) is excellent for both breakfast and dinner Just a fantastic stay. I would highly recommend to others, and we will definitely be back!!

Once again Carroll Villa Hotel provided us with a fabulous getaway weekend. The accommodations are great, the staff are friendly and welcoming and the location couldn’t be any better. The Mad Batter is the best restaurant in town, so why eat anywhere else ? We will keep coming back.