Stay Realm Logo

Discover

Hotels

Settings

Currency
Language
Loading...
9.6 / 10 Guest Rating

Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant

1301 Beach Avenue, Cape May, New Jersey, 08204, Cape May, US

Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant - main view

About the Property

Scenic Garden Views and Complimentary Amenities

At Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant, revel in the lush garden views and make use of perks like free Wi-Fi and wedding services. Enjoy a delectable meal at the on-site restaurant and mingle with other guests at the complimentary reception.

Charming Accommodations and Personalized Service

Feel at home in one of the 9 cozy guestrooms, each equipped with complimentary Wi-Fi, showers, and luxe toiletries. Benefit from the attentive front desk staff available during select hours and take advantage of free onsite parking.

Prime Location near Beach and Attractions

With Cape May Beach just steps away and Washington Street Mall a short 3-minute drive, Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant offers easy access to nearby attractions. Don't miss out on exploring Wildwood Boardwalk, a 7.3-mile drive from the inn, and Sunset Beach, only 4.3 miles away.

Book your stay at Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant in Cape May for a delightful seaside retreat.

Facilities & Amenities

Free WiFi
Garden
Wheelchair accessible
Bicycle rentals nearby
Front desk (limited hours)
Smoke-free property
Wedding services
Free reception
Free self parking
Computer station

Important Information

Check-in & Out

Check-in
Check-out11:00 AM

Property Notes

Children 12 years old and younger are not permitted at this adults-only property.

Check Room Availability

1 night · 2 adults

No rooms available

We couldn't find any available rooms for these dates and guests. Try adjusting your search criteria.

Guest Reviews

9.6
Exceptional75 verified reviews

Categories

Cleanliness9.6
Location9.8
Service9.2
Facilities9.0
Value for money8.9
Comfort9.5

Select topics to read reviews

H
hacc
Verified booking
Standard Room
Stayed in May 9, 2015

"Nice getaway"

10.0

The staff and amenities ( afternoon wine and cheese and the hospitality room) give PSI and edge over their completion. It was also great to have bicycles available for the guests' use.

Helpful?
B
Beth
Verified booking
Standard Room
Stayed in Apr 24, 2015

"Wonderful stay"

10.0

The hotel is lovely and our room, #3, was very cozy. It had a gas fireplace which warmed the room very quickly and gave great ambiance. Happy hour with wine, cheese and veggies was a wonderful way to relax upon arrival. Staff was friendly and wonderful. Breakfast was OK...we both had omelets and they were pretty ordinary....my son didn't like his sausage and I tasted it...didn't like it either. The yogurt with fruit and granola was the highlight for me. Unfortunately, being in Cape May during off season in late April was pretty quiet and many things were closed. However, we did enjoy our stay and it was wonderful to be across the street from the ocean.

Helpful?
M
maureen
Verified booking
Standard Room
Stayed in Dec 25, 2014

"excellent"

10.0

the service was excellent and attention to detail was superb

Helpful?
M
mobilfamily
Verified booking
Standard Room
Stayed in Dec 9, 2014

"Grand old B&B on the beach"

8.0

The facility was lovely. The breakfast was excellent. And the staff was most cordial. But.... We had two rooms on the same trip. There was a difference in room amenities despite the two rooms costing the same price. Three different wifi connections were offered, none of them worked for netbook, kindlefire, or iphone. If you have back problems, the beds are too soft. (We overheard other customers say the same thing on checking out.)

Helpful?
J
Jim
Verified booking
Standard Room
Stayed in Nov 20, 2014

"Old Charm, new amentities"

10.0

My wife and I have just returned from a two day stay at PSI. We were very impressed! The staff was exceptional, friendly and professional. The room was clean and fresh.Our room had a fireplace and modern bath. The Inn had a remodelling a few years ago. There is a nice common area where wine and cheese is served from six o'clock until 8 o'clock. We meet three couples there and had an enjoyable time chatting with them Tuesday night. Breakfast was served every day from 8:30 until 10;00. There were many choices and each was tasty and well prepared.. We plan on coming back again next October for another relaxing step back in time.

Helpful?
V
Verified traveler
Verified booking
Standard Room
Stayed in Nov 7, 2014

"Exceptional"

10.0

Loved having dinner on site. The 3 course fixed price menu offerred to guests was a great value. You have to bring your own wine but we enjoyed this option as we could bring a great bottle for a reasonable price.

Helpful?
L
linda
Verified booking
Standard Room
Stayed in Oct 19, 2014

"Cape May"

10.0

My husband and I stayed at the PSI for 3 nights. The place is beautiful with lots of amenities. The food was excellent. The staff is helpful and friendly. We did have one issue with the room. There were ants in the bathroom. We told housekeeping several times. One spritz of Raid would have solved the problem. The extra quests in our room were still crawling about when we left. So check the room carefully. For the price ants should not be included.

Helpful?
P
Paul
Verified booking
Standard Room
Stayed in Oct 10, 2014

"Anniversary Get Away"

10.0

The staff was wonderful! The breakfast was yummy! The room was lovely, and of course the restaurant is always exceptional!

Helpful?
L
Linda
Verified booking
Standard Room
Stayed in Aug 24, 2014

"tranquil, upscale, peaceful retreat"

10.0

From the moment we stepped inside the doors we felt like royalty, every need was met, we never had to ask for a thing...peter shields is an oasis among inns a place to relax and kick back and enjoy.the food and service and cleanliness were amazing...

Helpful?
H
Howie
Verified booking
Standard Room
Stayed in Jul 27, 2014

"Beautiful place to stay!"

10.0

Our stay at PSI was wonderful. The restaurant was delicious. The room (room 5) was beautiful and homey! I cannot recommend PSI more. From the outside it is quaint and well kept. From the inside it is warm, friendly and filled with aromas from the world class restaurant. Every employee we encountered was friendly and helpful. If you are in the area, stay at PSI. YOU WILL LOVE IT!!'

Helpful?